Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan vs Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Wool Cardigan
Buy the Draper James if you want an easy, machine-friendly cotton cardigan at a slightly lower price. Buy the Reformation Bernadette if you want a cropped, all-wool piece with a traceable fiber story. As of November 3, 2026, the Draper James is $118.00 at Poshmark and the Reformation is $120.00 at Mercari, a $2 gap.
Today the Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan costs $2.00 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan
Choose the Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan if you want a lightweight cotton-blend layer you can wear often without dry cleaning.
- Cotton-dominant knit breathes and layers well
- Lower price at $118.00 at Poshmark
- Fair Isle trim gives it a classic look
- Easy care compared with wool
What separates them
| Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan | Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Wool Cardigan | |
|---|---|---|
| Fiber | 96% cotton, 4% nylon | 100% traceable NATIVA wool |
| Length | 20 1/2 inches, hits at hip | Cropped |
| Pattern | Fair Isle bands in blue and green on ivory | All-over polka dot print |
| Care | Not stated; cotton blend is generally washable | Dry clean only |
| Fit | Standard crewneck, button front | Relaxed fit, ribbed trims |
| Price, November 3, 2026 | $118.00 at Poshmark | $120.00 at Mercari |
| Sourcing claim | None stated | Traceable NATIVA wool; Climate Pledge member |
Price history
- Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan: lowest $118.00 on Nov 3 at Draper James.
- Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Wool Cardigan: lowest $120.00 on Nov 3 at Mercari.
Prices at every store
Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan
- PoshmarkNew
In stock
$118.00+ $6.49 shippingObserved at 1:20 PM - Draper JamesNew
In stock
$118.00+ $8.95 shippingObserved at 1:19 PM
Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Wool Cardigan
- MercariNew
In stock
$120.00+ $7.48 shippingObserved at 1:20 PM - PoshmarkNew
In stock
$169.00+ $6.49 shippingObserved at 1:19 PM
Specs compared
| Spec | Draper James Polka Dot Cardigan | Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Wool Cardigan |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 20 1/2" | cropped |
| Neckline | Crewneck | crewneck |
| Material composition | 96% COTTON, 4% NYLON | — |
| Material | — | 100% traceable NATIVA™️ wool |
| Fit | — | relaxed fit |
| Sleeve length | — | long-sleeved |
| Closure | — | functional button front |
| Care | — | Dry clean only |
| Made in | — | China |
| Pattern | — | all-over polka-dot print |
| Trims |
What reviewers say
Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Wool Cardigan
Reformation knitwear generally draws praise for softness and a flattering cut, with the Bernadette cardigan noted for its cropped fit and print. Common complaints center on wool itch and the dry-clean requirement.
- Soft, lightweight feel for a wool knit
- Cropped fit works well with high-waisted bottoms
- Print looks more polished in person than in photos
- Some find the wool scratchy against skin
- Dry clean only adds upkeep cost
- Cropped length runs short on taller wearers
Questions and answers
- Which is warmer, the Draper James or the Reformation cardigan?
- The Reformation Bernadette, because it is 100% wool. The Draper James is a cotton-nylon knit and is described as lightweight, so it suits milder days and layering.
- Which one is easier to care for?
- The Draper James. Its cotton blend is generally washable, while the Reformation Bernadette is dry clean only.
- Is the Reformation worth $2 more?
- If you want traceable wool and a cropped cut, yes. The price gap is small: $120.00 at Mercari versus $118.00 at Poshmark as of November 3, 2026.
- Which fits better for high-waisted jeans?
- The Reformation Bernadette. Its cropped, relaxed fit is cut to sit at the waist; the Draper James runs 20 1/2 inches and hits nearer the hip.
- Do both have a button front?
- Yes. Both are crewneck cardigans with a functional button placket.