Edikted Shea Polka Dot Cardigan vs Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Cardigan

The Reformation Bernadette is the better-made cardigan: 100% traceable NATIVA wool, ribbed trims and a cropped, relaxed cut that holds its shape. The Edikted Shea is a polyester-rayon knit with a round neck and a longer, regular fit, and it is the easier one to throw on and wash at home. Reviewers of the Edikted praise it as a nice everyday cardigan, though its rating rests on only 12 reviews; Reformation's wool knit is widely regarded as the more durable, warmer piece. Buy the Reformation if you want a wool cardigan you keep for years; buy the Edikted if you want a soft, casual polka-dot layer with simple care.

• Choose the Edikted Shea if you want a soft polyester-rayon cardigan with a round neck, regular length and easy hand-wash care for casual wear.
• Choose the Reformation Bernadette if you want a cropped, relaxed-fit cardigan in 100% traceable wool with ribbed trims that will hold up over seasons.