Reformation Bernadette Polka Dot Cardigan vs Jessica London Fine Gauge Cardigan

The Reformation Bernadette is the pick for a warm, cropped statement cardigan in traceable wool with a real polka-dot print. The Jessica London is the pick for plus-size shoppers who want a lightweight, machine-washable layering cardigan with hip coverage. The Reformation wins on material and design; the Jessica London wins on easy care, size range and everyday layering. Owners of fine-gauge cotton blends report they hold shape but pill over time, while wool knits like the Bernadette need gentler handling and dry cleaning.

• Choose the Reformation Bernadette if you want a cropped wool cardigan with a bold polka-dot print and you don't mind dry cleaning.
• Choose the Jessica London if you want a lightweight plus-size button-front cardigan you can machine wash and layer all year.