EMS Avery Women's Long Padded Jacket vs Barbour Winter Beadnell Waterproof

The Barbour Winter Beadnell is the better pick for wet, windy city winters and for anyone who wants a hood built in. The EMS Avery is the warmer of the two on paper, with a longer body and a lab-tested cold rating, and it costs far less for comparable waterproofing. Build quality favors Barbour: its polyurethane membrane shell and tartan lining feel more substantial, and owners of the Beadnell line praise its longevity. The EMS is the value choice for a long, warm commuter coat; the Barbour is the step up for a hooded, breathable rain shell with a classic look.

• Choose the EMS Avery if you want maximum warmth and length for cold, wet winter days and you prefer a longer coat without a hood.
• Choose the Barbour Winter Beadnell if you want a hooded, breathable waterproof jacket with a classic tartan-lined look and a more premium build.