Kirkham Women's Long Insulated Jacket vs EMS Avery Women's Long Padded Jacket

The EMS Avery is the better pick if you get caught in real rain: taped seams and a 5,000mm waterproof rating beat the Kirkham's water-repellent coating, which only handles showers. The Kirkham is the warmer, more flattering everyday coat, with recycled padding, an adjustable waist and a toggle hood, and its 4.7 rating from 573 owners backs that up. The Avery is midweight and cut long, so it suits wet commutes and winter walks more than deep cold. Neither is a mountaineering shell.

• Choose the Kirkham if you want a warm, shaped winter coat for cold dry days and light showers, and you like an adjustable waist and hood.
• Choose the EMS Avery if rain is your main enemy and you want taped seams and a tested waterproof shell over maximum warmth.