Kirkham Women's Long Insulated Jacket vs Barbour Winter Beadnell Waterproof

The Barbour Winter Beadnell is the better wet-weather coat: its polyurethane membrane is genuinely waterproof and breathable, while the Kirkham only has a water-repellent coating that sheds light rain. The Kirkham is the warmer, more flattering option, with recycled padding, princess seams, waist toggles and a longer cut, and its 4.7 rating from 573 owners backs that up. The Beadnell has far fewer ratings (4.4 from 21), so treat its score with caution. Pick the Kirkham for cold dry winter days and a shaped fit; pick the Beadnell for steady rain and a classic tartan-lined look.

• Choose the Kirkham if you want a warm, shaped long coat for cold dry winter days and light showers, and you prefer recycled padding and a cinched waist.
• Choose the Barbour Winter Beadnell if you expect real rain, want a fully waterproof and breathable shell, and like a regular-fit longline coat with tartan lining.