Which is better for a high-traffic living room?

The Medallion. Its 0.3-inch cut-and-loop pile and stain-resistant polypropylene are built for busy rooms, and the non-slip backing keeps it in place.

Which feels softer underfoot?

The Ivy. Its 0.7-inch high pile is more than twice as thick as the Medallion's 0.3-inch pile.

The Medallion's low loop pile resists crushing better in walkways. The Ivy's nylon blend adds strength, but high pile mats down faster in heavy traffic.

Is the Ivy worth the extra $1.75?

Only if you want a plusher, patterned rug. At $55.59 at Lowe's versus $53.84 at eBay as of November 8, 2026, the price gap is small, so pick on pile height and look.

Do either have a non-slip backing?

The Medallion has a latex non-slip backing. The Ivy's listing does not specify one, so add a pad on hard floors.

Which is easier to clean?

The Medallion. Its low pile vacuums easily and it is spot clean only. The Ivy's high pile holds more dirt and needs more frequent vacuuming.

Garland Rug Medallion Sage Square Rug vs Garland Rug Ivy Area Rug 12x12

Both are 12-foot Garland rugs in the same price range, so the choice comes down to construction and look. The Medallion is a low 0.3-inch cut-and-loop rug with a non-slip latex backing, which suits high-traffic rooms and hard floors. The Ivy is a thicker 0.7-inch high-pile rug with a floral pattern and a 4.1 rating from 943 ratings. At the latest prices, the Medallion is $53.84 at eBay and the Ivy is $55.59 at Lowe's, as of November 8, 2026, a gap of under $2.

Today the Garland Rug Medallion Sage Square Rug costs $1.75 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.