Which is better for a high-traffic living room?

The Garland Medallion. Its stain-resistant polypropylene and non-slip latex backing are built for heavy foot traffic, and it costs less.

Which rug is softer underfoot?

The SAFAVIEH Monaco, with a 3/8 in pile against the Garland's 0.3 in. The difference is small but noticeable.

Is the SAFAVIEH Monaco worth the extra money?

Only if you want its geometric pattern and slightly thicker pile. Otherwise the Garland saves about $7 and adds a non-slip backing.

Do either of these need a rug pad?

The Garland does not, thanks to its latex non-slip backing. The Monaco has no non-slip backing, so a pad is recommended on hardwood.

Which is easier to clean?

Both are spot clean only. The Garland's stain-resistant treatment gives it an edge in messy rooms, and neither is machine washable.

Are both rugs really 12 ft squares?

The Garland is listed as a 12 ft square and the Monaco as a 12 ft square, but both listings also show smaller sizes. Confirm the exact dimensions with the store before you buy.

Garland Rug Medallion Sage Square Rug vs SAFAVIEH Monaco Square Rug 6'7"

Buy the Garland Medallion if you want a plain, stain-resistant square rug with a non-slip latex backing for a high-traffic room. Buy the SAFAVIEH Monaco if you want a patterned, boho-style rug and don't mind adding a rug pad. The Garland is the cheaper option at $53.84 at eBay as of November 8, 2026, against $60.87 at Amazon for the Monaco.

Today the Garland Rug Medallion Sage Square Rug costs $7.03 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.