Which is better for a patio or deck?

The Nourison Positano. It is built for indoor/outdoor use and can be hosed down and air dried. The Garland Ivy is indoor only.

Which is softer underfoot?

The Garland Ivy. Its high pile is about 0.7 in. thick, while the Nourison is a 0.25 in. flatweave with almost no cushion.

Is the Nourison worth it over the Garland?

It costs $6.59 less at $49.00 at Walmart versus $55.59 at Lowe's as of November 8, 2026, and is rated higher. Pick the Garland only if you want a plush indoor rug.

The Nourison's flatweave and serged edges resist wear and moisture better, and it is rated for moderate traffic. The Garland's high pile mats and soils faster in busy rooms.

Are either good with pets?

The Nourison is listed as not pet friendly. The Garland does not state pet suitability, and its high pile holds hair and dirt, so neither is a strong pick for pets.

Which is easier to clean?

The Nourison. Rinse it with a hose and air dry. The Garland needs vacuuming and spot cleaning, and its thick pile holds moisture longer.

Garland Rug Ivy Area Rug 12x12 vs Nourison Home Positano Terracotta Rug

Buy the Nourison Positano if you want a low-pile, indoor/outdoor rug that hoses clean and costs less: $49.00 at Walmart as of November 8, 2026. Buy the Garland Rug Ivy if you want a thick, soft high-pile rug for a bedroom or living room, at $55.59 at Lowe's as of November 8, 2026. The Nourison is rated higher (4.7 from 323 ratings vs 4.1 from 943) and is cheaper, but it is thin and not pet friendly.

Today the Nourison Home Positano Terracotta Rug costs $6.59 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.