Great Value Soft & Strong Toilet Paper vs Angel Soft 2-Ply Toilet Paper

Both are unscented 2-ply embossed toilet paper that is septic safe, so the choice comes down to roll size and how much you want on hand. Angel Soft has the stronger reputation: about 4.7 out of 5 from over 519,000 ratings, with owners calling it soft, strong and long-lasting between roll changes. Great Value Soft & Strong sits at 4.6 from about 164,000 ratings and is a solid everyday pick, but its sheets per roll are not clearly stated, so Angel Soft is the safer buy when softness and consistency matter.

• Choose the Great Value Soft & Strong if you want a smaller 12-roll pack to try first or have limited storage, and you are fine with a store brand that most owners rate well.
• Choose the Angel Soft if you want a large 36-mega-roll supply, softness that holds up in owner reviews, and SFI-sourced paper.