Great Value Soft & Strong Toilet Paper vs Cottonelle Ultra Soft Toilet Paper

Buy the Great Value pack if you want a large, no-frills supply: 12 mega rolls equal 48 regular rolls, the sheets are 2-ply and embossed, and it is septic-safe. Buy Cottonelle Ultra Soft if softness matters more than sheet count; it is the plusher, thicker-feeling paper and the brand most owners already trust. Both are unscented and white. Great Value wins on how much paper you get per pack and on its very large rating base; Cottonelle wins on feel and on how reliably it holds up when wet.

• Choose the Great Value Soft & Strong if you want the most paper per pack, a simple 2-ply sheet and a septic-safe roll for a busy household.
• Choose the Cottonelle Ultra Soft if you care most about a soft, thick sheet and want a brand with a long track record in bathrooms.