Kirkham Women's Long Insulated Jacket vs Columbia Suttle Mountain Long Jacket

The Columbia Suttle Mountain Long is the better technical winter coat: Omni-Heat reflective lining, synthetic down, a storm hood and a looser fit that layers over thick knits. The Kirkham is the more flattering, dressier long coat, with princess seams, waist toggles and a cleaner silhouette, and its 4.7 rating from 573 owners backs the fit and warmth. Both are water-repellent rather than fully waterproof shells, so neither replaces a rain jacket. Buy the Kirkham for shape and everyday town wear; buy the Columbia for colder, more active days and a roomier fit.

• Choose the Kirkham if you want a shaped, flattering long coat for cold commutes and everyday wear, and you are around average height or taller.
• Choose the Columbia if you want maximum warmth, a roomier layer-over-layers fit and a hood built for wind and light snow.