StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box vs Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread

Buy the Levain box if you want big, gooey American-style cookies in four flavors; buy Mary Macleod's if you want 18 crisp chocolate shortbread in a gold gift box. Levain gives you 8 six-ounce cookies; Mary Macleod's gives you 18 shortbread. Levain's cookies are hand-made and warm up gooey in a few minutes; Mary Macleod's shortbread uses real creamery butter and Belgian chocolate and holds up in shipping. Compare current store prices on this page before deciding.

  • Choose the Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box if you want four different gooey cookies, each about 6 ounces, and a gift that gets eaten fast.
  • Choose the Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box if you want 18 crunchy chocolate shortbread in a gold-embellished box that travels well.

Prices

  • Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box: $49.99 at Foodie City Network (last seen Nov 20)
  • Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread: $39.95 at Sur La Table (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread is $10.04 cheaper than the Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box at the latest prices (Nov 10 and Nov 20)
Levain Bakery
Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

$49.99at Foodie City NetworkChecked Nov 20
See all prices and details
Visit Foodie City Network
Pros
  • Four distinct flavors in one box, no substitutions.
  • Large 6-ounce cookies feel substantial as a gift.
  • Warms up gooey in a 350-degree oven in a few minutes.
  • Freezes well if not eaten right away.
  • Gift wrapping options are available.
Cons
  • Contains wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, soy and walnuts; not allergen-free.
  • Only 8 cookies per box.
  • Gooey texture depends on warming; not crunchy.
  • Best within about a week.
Mary Macleod's
Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Ribbon Chocolate Crunch Shortbread

Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread

Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Ribbon Chocolate Crunch Shortbread

4.9(8 ratings)
$39.95at Sur La TableChecked Nov 10
See all prices and details
Visit Sur La Table
Pros
  • 18 cookies per box, more pieces to share.
  • Crunchy shortbread holds up in shipping and storage.
  • Gold-embellished box is presentation-ready.
  • Single chocolate crunch flavor suits a crowd.
  • Fits holidays and any special occasion.
  • Made with real creamery butter and Belgian chocolate.
Cons
  • Only one flavor.
  • Crunchy shortbread is not gooey or warm-and-serve.
  • Smaller pieces than Levain's 6-ounce cookies.
  • Allergen and shelf-life details are not stated.

What separates them

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift BoxMary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread
Cookie count8 cookies18 cookies
Cookie size6 ounces eachNot stated; shortbread is smaller
TextureGooey when warmedCrunchy shortbread
Flavor rangeFour flavors: Chocolate Chip Walnut, Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter ChipOne flavor: Chocolate Crunch
PackagingCellophane bags with hand-tied blue ribbons in a gift boxGold-embellished Signature Gold gift box
AllergensWheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, soy, walnuts; not allergen-freeNot stated
Shelf lifeAbout one week in an airtight container, or freezeNot stated; shortbread typically keeps longer
Best forDessert and snacking, especially warmedHoliday gifting and shipping
Gift extrasGift wrapping options availablePresentation-ready gold-embellished box
Occasion fitGifting and dessertHolidays and any special occasion

Price history

$55.00$26.60
Oct 31Nov 20
  • Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box: lowest $49.99 on Oct 31 at Foodie City Network; $49.99 on Nov 20.
  • Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread: lowest $26.60 on Oct 31 at Macy's; $38.00 on Nov 20.

Prices at every store

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

  • Foodie City NetworkNew

    In stock

    $49.99Checked Nov 20
    Visit Foodie City Network
  • GoodyNew

    In stock

    $55.00+ $15.00 shippingChecked Nov 10
    Visit Goody
  • Levain BakeryNew

    Availability unknown

    $52.00+ $20.00 shippingChecked Nov 20
    Visit Levain Bakery
All 3 stores and price history →

Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread

  • Sur La TableNew

    In stock

    $39.95+ $8.99 shippingChecked Nov 10
    Visit Sur La Table
  • Macy'sNew

    In stock

    $38.00+ $10.95 shippingChecked Nov 20
    Visit Macy's
  • ModeSensNew

    In stock

    $38.00+ $11.00 shippingChecked Nov 20
    Visit ModeSens
  • GoldbellyNew

    In stock

    $49.95+ $10.00 shippingChecked Nov 20
    Visit Goldbelly

Also available at

  • Bloomingdale'sCheck price at Bloomingdale's
All 4 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecLevain Bakery Cookie Gift BoxMary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread
OccasionGiftingHolidays, Any special occasion
Cookie TextureGooey (when warmed)Crunch
Cookie Count8 cookies18
Packaging TypeGift boxSignature Gold Gift Box, Gold-embellished box
Typical UsersGiftingGifting
Fresh Or FrozenFresh (baked daily)—
Cookie ConsistencyGooey (when warmed)—
Secondary FlavorWalnut—
AllergensWheat, Dairy, Eggs, Peanuts, Soy—
ContainsWalnut, Peanut Butter Chip, Raisin—
Free OfNot allergen-free—
Packaging Size10.00 in (Width)—
Show all 14 specsShow fewer specs
SpecLevain Bakery Cookie Gift BoxMary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread
Cookie Type—Shortbread
Highlighted Flavors—Chocolate Crunch

What reviewers say

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

Levain's cookies are widely praised for their size, crisp outside and gooey center, and the gift box is a popular way to send them.

What people mention
  • TexturePraisedOwners describe a crisp edge and a soft, gooey middle, especially after a few minutes in the oven.
  • SizePraisedReviewers repeatedly mention how large and filling the 6-ounce cookies are.
  • SweetnessMixedMany love the richness, but some say the cookies are too sweet to finish in one sitting.
  • AllergensCriticisedThe walnuts, peanuts and shared equipment make the box off-limits for some recipients.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a holiday gift?
Mary Macleod's, with 18 shortbread in a gold-embellished box that ships and stores well. Levain is better if the recipient loves big gooey cookies and will eat them within a week.
Which has more cookies?
Mary Macleod's has 18 shortbread; Levain has 8 cookies. Levain's are much larger at 6 ounces each.
Which lasts longer?
Mary Macleod's crunchy shortbread typically keeps longer than Levain's gooey cookies, which are best within about a week or frozen.
Is Levain safe for nut allergies?
No. Levain lists wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, soy and walnuts, and says it is not an allergen-free bakery. Mary Macleod's allergen details are not stated, so check the label.
Which is better for sharing at an office?
Mary Macleod's, since 18 smaller shortbread pieces divide more easily. Levain's 8 large cookies are better for a small group or a single recipient.
Is one worth stepping up to?
It depends on what you value. Levain gives size and four flavors; Mary Macleod's gives count and packaging. Compare current store prices on this page.
What are Levain's cookies made with?
Levain bakes by hand on shared equipment that also processes dairy, peanuts, soy, tree nuts and wheat. The box mixes Chocolate Chip Walnut, Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin and Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip, with no substitutions.
What makes Mary Macleod's shortbread different?
It is a crunchy shortbread built on real creamery butter and Belgian chocolate, sold in one flavor. That gives it a firmer bite and longer shipping life than Levain's gooey cookies.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box vs The #1 NY Cookie
  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Ribbon Chocolate Crunch Shortbread