Star Cookies NY Cookie Box vs Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Shortbread

Buy the NY Cookie box if you want big, soft, stuffed cookies baked to order and shipped fast; buy Mary Macleod's if you want a shelf-stable, elegantly boxed shortbread to give as a gift. The NY cookies are roughly 95g each and come in a build-your-own box of 30, so they suit sharing and eating fresh. Mary Macleod's gives you 18 crunch shortbreads in a gold gift box, a firmer, more buttery bite that travels well. Owners rate the NY Cookie 4.7 from over 7,000 ratings; Mary Macleod's reputation rests on its butter-and-Belgian-chocolate shortbread rather than a large public rating count.

• Choose the NY Cookie if you want oversized soft-baked cookies with pick-your-own flavors, delivered fresh within days of ordering.
• Choose Mary Macleod's if you need a presentable gold gift box of buttery chocolate shortbread that keeps well and needs no refrigeration.