StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box vs Star Cookies NY Cookie Box

Buy the Levain gift box for a gift you want to look and feel like Levain: four named flavors, cellophane bags, hand-tied blue ribbons, and the dense 6-ounce cookie people know from the bakery. Buy The #1 NY Cookie for a bigger, build-your-own box of oversized stuffed cookies shipped fresh after you order. Levain wins on brand recognition and gift presentation; The #1 NY Cookie wins on choice, volume and per-cookie size, and its 4.7 rating from over 7,000 shoppers is strong. Neither is allergen-free, and both are best warmed.

  • Choose the Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box if you want a recognizable bakery gift with four classic flavors and ribbon-tied packaging.
  • Choose The #1 NY Cookie if you want to pick your own flavors in a large box of oversized stuffed cookies baked after you order.

Prices

  • Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box: $55.00 at Goody (last seen Nov 10)
  • Star Cookies NY Cookie Box: $10.00 at Star Cookies (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the Star Cookies NY Cookie Box is $45.00 cheaper than the Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box at the latest prices (Nov 10)
Levain Bakery
Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

$55.00at GoodyChecked Nov 10
See all prices and details
Visit Goody
Pros
  • Recognizable Levain name and signature cookie
  • Four classic flavors in one box
  • Ribbon-tied cellophane bags and gift wrap options
  • Dense 6-ounce cookies that go gooey when warmed
Cons
  • No substitutions, so picky eaters are stuck
  • Includes walnuts, peanuts and raisins
  • Not allergen-free; shared equipment
  • Smaller cookies and fewer per box than B
T
The #1 NY Cookie

Star Cookies NY Cookie Box

The #1 NY Cookie

4.7(7,050 ratings)
$10.00at Star CookiesChecked Nov 10
See all prices and details
Visit Star Cookies
Pros
  • Build your own box across flavors
  • 8-ounce cookies, larger than Levain's
  • Baked after you order and shipped in under 48 hours
  • 4.7 out of 5 from 7,050 ratings
Cons
  • No ribbon or gift-wrap presentation noted
  • 30-piece boxes may be more than a small gift needs
  • Allergen details are less spelled out than Levain's
  • Less brand recognition than Levain

What separates them

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift BoxStar Cookies NY Cookie Box
Flavor choiceFixed assortment: one of each of the four original flavors, no substitutionsBuild your own box: you pick the flavors
Cookie size6 ounces per cookie8 ounces per cookie
Box size8 cookies in this box (also sold in 4 and 12)Boxes of 30 pieces
Freshness modelBaked daily, then shippedBaked after you order and shipped in under 48 hours
Gift presentationCellophane bags with hand-tied blue ribbons, gift wrap optionsStandard box, no ribbon or gift wrap noted
TextureThick, gooey when warmedCrispy outside, soft and melty inside
Brand recognitionWell-known NYC bakery with a signature cookieSmaller Orlando bakery with a strong 4.7 rating from 7,050 shoppers
AllergensWheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, soy, walnuts; shared equipmentMade with real butter, eggs and chocolate; check the label for allergens

Price history

$55.00$49.99
Oct 31Nov 10
  • Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box: lowest $49.99 on Oct 31 at Foodie City Network; $55.00 on Nov 10.

Prices at every store

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

  • GoodyNew

    In stock

    $55.00+ $15.00 shippingChecked Nov 10
    Visit Goody
  • Foodie City NetworkNew

    Availability unknown

    $49.99Checked Oct 31
    Visit Foodie City Network
  • Levain BakeryNew

    Availability unknown

    $52.00Checked Oct 31
    Visit Levain Bakery
Prices and history →

Star Cookies NY Cookie Box

  • Star CookiesNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $10.00Checked Nov 10
    Visit Star Cookies
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecLevain Bakery Cookie Gift BoxStar Cookies NY Cookie Box
OccasionGifting—
Cookie TextureGooey (when warmed)—
Fresh Or FrozenFresh (baked daily)—
Cookie ConsistencyGooey (when warmed)—
Secondary FlavorWalnut—
AllergensWheat, Dairy, Eggs, Peanuts, Soy—
ContainsWalnut, Peanut Butter Chip, Raisin—
Free OfNot allergen-free—
Cookie Count8 cookies—
Packaging TypeGift box—
Packaging Size10.00 in (Width)—
Typical UsersGifting—
Show all 14 specsShow fewer specs
SpecLevain Bakery Cookie Gift BoxStar Cookies NY Cookie Box
Pack size—boxes of 30 pieces
Piece weight—95g

What reviewers say

Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box

Levain's cookies are widely praised for their size, crisp outside and gooey center, and the gift box is a popular way to send them.

What people mention
  • TexturePraisedOwners describe a crisp edge and a soft, gooey middle, especially after a few minutes in the oven.
  • SizePraisedReviewers repeatedly mention how large and filling the 6-ounce cookies are.
  • SweetnessMixedMany love the richness, but some say the cookies are too sweet to finish in one sitting.
  • AllergensCriticisedThe walnuts, peanuts and shared equipment make the box off-limits for some recipients.

Star Cookies NY Cookie Box

  • 4.7 / 57,050 ratings

With 4.7 out of 5 across more than 7,000 ratings, buyers mostly praise the size, the gooey texture and the fresh-baked arrival. Complaints center on sweetness and richness.

What people mention
  • SizePraisedBuyers say each cookie is big enough to split or save for later.
  • TexturePraisedReviewers like the crisp edge and soft, melty center.
  • FreshnessPraisedOwners report the cookies arrive fresh and well sealed.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a gift?
Levain, for the ribbon-tied bags, gift wrap options and the name people recognize. The #1 NY Cookie is the better pick if the recipient cares more about choosing flavors and getting big cookies.
Which gives bigger cookies?
The #1 NY Cookie. Its cookies are 8 ounces each; Levain's are 6 ounces.
Can I choose flavors in the Levain box?
No. The assortment is fixed at one of each of the four original flavors, and Levain states no substitutions. The #1 NY Cookie lets you build your own box.
Which lasts longer?
Levain says its cookies keep in an airtight container for up to a week or can be frozen. The #1 NY Cookie ships fresh after baking; freeze extras either way.
Are either safe for nut or gluten allergies?
No. Levain contains wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, soy and walnuts and is made on shared equipment. Check The #1 NY Cookie's label before buying for an allergy.
Is The #1 NY Cookie worth stepping up to over Levain?
If you want more cookies, bigger cookies and flavor choice, yes. If the gift needs to look like a bakery present, Levain is the safer choice.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Levain Bakery Cookie Gift Box vs Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Ribbon Chocolate Crunch Shortbread
  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Signature Cookie Assortment
  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Gourmet Cookie Three-Pack
  • The #1 NY Cookie vs Mary Macleod's Signature Gold Gift Box Ribbon Chocolate Crunch Shortbread

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best gourmet cookies to buy online
Sweetness
Criticised
Some buyers find the cookies overly sweet and rich.