Ashley Luigi Oversized Chair and Ottoman vs Anselmo Leather Recliner & Ottoman

Buy the Luigi if you want a wide, low-slung chair with a big ottoman and a leather-look finish at a lower outlay. Buy the Anselmo if you want a genuine leather recliner with a mid-century look and a mechanism that leans back. The Luigi is 50 inches wide with track arms and semi-attached tufted back, and its leather match means real leather on the seating surfaces with matching faux leather elsewhere. The Anselmo is a smaller recliner with button tufting, sinuous springs and a solid hardwood and bent plywood frame; its 4.2 out of 5 rating from 35 owners is decent but not glowing.

• Choose the Luigi if you want an oversized, wide chair with a matching ottoman and a contemporary look.
• Choose the Anselmo if you want a genuine leather recliner that leans back and fits a smaller room.