Ashley Luigi Oversized Chair and Ottoman vs Stressless Mayfair Classic Power Recliner

The Luigi is a big, wide lounge chair with a matching ottoman, built for sprawling rather than fine-tuning. The Stressless Mayfair is a powered recliner with a 360° swivel, adjustable lumbar and head support, and a lay-flat recline, so it costs more but does far more. Buy the Luigi for a casual living room where two people share the seat and looks matter more than ergonomics. Buy the Mayfair if you want one seat that adjusts to your back and you plan to read or watch TV in it for hours.

• Choose the Luigi if you want a wide, low-key leather chair and ottoman set that suits a contemporary living room and seats two in a pinch.
• Choose the Stressless Mayfair if you want a powered recliner that swivels, supports your lower back and head, and lies nearly flat.