Ashley Luigi Oversized Chair and Ottoman vs Carianna Oversized Chair and Ottoman

The Carianna is the better-rounded pick for most shoppers. It is a true chair-and-a-half with a 54-inch width, a 23-inch seat depth and a 22-inch seat height, and owners rate it 5 out of 5 across 12 ratings. The Luigi is wider overall at 50 inches but has a shallower 41-inch depth and a semi-attached tufted back, and its leather is leather match, meaning the seating surfaces are leather and the rest is faux leather. Pick the Luigi for a low, contemporary leather look with a big 34-inch ottoman; pick the Carianna for a taller, deeper seat and traditional roll arms with nailhead trim.

• Choose the Luigi if you want a contemporary leather chair with tufted detailing and a wide ottoman to share.
• Choose the Carianna if you want a taller, deeper chair-and-a-half with traditional roll arms and nailhead trim.