Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat vs Mainstays Oval Bubble Bath Tub Mat

These are the same Mainstays oval bubble mat in two colors, so the choice comes down to looks and how much feedback you want from other buyers. The charcoal version has far more ratings, which gives a steadier picture of how it holds up. The clear version shows the tub floor and any mildew or soap film underneath, so it needs more frequent washing. Both are thin vinyl with suction cups that grip best on smooth, non-textured tubs.

• Choose the charcoal Mainstays mat if you want a neutral dark mat that hides water spots and soap scum and has the larger track record of owner ratings.
• Choose the clear Mainstays mat if you want a barely visible mat that lets your tub's finish show through.