Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat vs Max Grip Bathtub Mat

The Mainstays Oval Bubble Mat is the safer bet for most shoppers: it has a large, verifiable review base at 4.3 stars and a simple vinyl build that machine washes. The Max Grip Bathtub Mat claims far more grip hardware — 200 suction cups and 176 drain holes — and a higher rating, but that rating rests on only 52 reviews, so treat it as promising rather than proven. Pick the Max Grip if drainage and suction count are your priority; pick the Mainstays if you want a known quantity with a neutral charcoal look.

• Choose the Mainstays Oval Bubble Mat if you want a well-reviewed, neutral charcoal mat with a cushioned bubble surface and easy machine-wash care.
• Choose the Max Grip Bathtub Mat if maximum suction coverage and heavy drainage matter more to you than a long track record.