Which is better for a slippery tub?

The Mainstays grips harder because of its suction cups, so it is the safer pick on a smooth tub floor. The Secure Mat relies on a non-slip backing, which can slide on a wet, curved surface.

Which resists mold better?

The Secure Mat. Its draining surface and Microban treatment are designed to stop mold and mildew from growing underneath. The Mainstays traps some water under the bubbles and needs regular washing and drying.

The Mainstays vinyl holds up but can stiffen and discolor. The Secure Mat's fabric top can fray or peel. Neither is built to last for decades, despite the marketing.

Is the Secure Mat worth stepping up to?

Yes if you want a larger, softer mat that drains and resists mold. No if you mainly want strong suction and easy machine washing.

Does the Secure Mat fit a standard tub?

At 32 x 16 in it fits most standard tubs, but the listing also gives a 14.2 in width, so measure your tub floor before buying. The Mainstays oval is smaller and fits tighter spaces.

Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat vs Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat

Buy the Mainstays Oval Bubble if you want a cheap, simple tub mat with strong suction cups and a cushioned bubble surface. Buy the Secure Mat if you want a larger mat with a draining, mold-inhibiting top layer and a softer feel. Owners rate the Secure Mat higher (4.7 vs 4.3), but the Mainstays is machine washable and easier to replace. Build quality is close: both are PVC-based, and neither is a premium fixture.

Choose the Secure Mat if you want a bigger, softer mat whose surface drains water and resists mold and mildew between washes.
Choose the Mainstays Oval Bubble if you want a simple oval tub mat that grips with suction cups and can go in the washing machine.

Prices

Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat: $23.04 at Amazon (checked today)
Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat: $9.96 at Walmart (checked today)
Difference: the Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat is $13.08 cheaper than the Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat today

Secure Mat - The Ultimate Non-Slip Bath Mat

	Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat	Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat
Size and shape	32 x 16 in rectangle, though the listing also states 14.2 in wide	15.25 x 27 in oval
Surface	Soft, cushiony fabric top that drains water through	Raised PVC bubble pattern with a cushioned feel
Mold and mildew	Microban antibacterial treatment built into the material	No antimicrobial treatment; relies on washing and hanging to dry
Grip	Non-slip backing; no suction cups listed	Suction cups on the bottom hold it to smooth tub surfaces
Cleaning	Marketed as needing no washing	Machine washable, hang to dry
Durability	Fabric top can fray or peel over years of use	Vinyl can stiffen and discolor, but is cheap to replace
Owner ratings	4.7 out of 5 from 2,320 ratings	4.3 out of 5 from 1,722 ratings

Spec	Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat	Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat
Size	32" X 16"	15.25" x 27"
Material	Polyester, Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)	Vinyl
Color	Black	Black
Width	14.2 in wide	15.25 in
Item Weight	1000 g	—
Brand	LKYJD	—
actual_color	—	Charcoal
multipack_quantity	—	1
Placement	—	Bath tub
Product Type	—	Tub Mat, Bath Mat
Rug Size	—	15.25 in x 27 in
Length	—	27"

Spec	Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat	Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat
Shape	—	Oval
Pattern	—	Bubble
Thickness	—	1.27 cm
Typical Users	—	UNISEX
Care Highlights	—	Machine wash, Hang to dry

Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat vs Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat

Prices

Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat vs Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat

Prices

Mainstays Oval Bubble Bathtub Mat

What separates them

Price history

Prices at every store