Which kit is better for a beginner?

The SHANY kit, because it includes foundation, mascara and a brush, so a beginner gets a full face from one box. The Miss Rose kit gives more shades but no foundation or mascara.

Which has more eyeshadow colors?

Miss Rose, with 39 eyeshadows against an unstated but smaller palette in the SHANY kit. Miss Rose also adds 6 blushes and 4 powders.

Is the Miss Rose kit worth the extra?

It depends on price at checkout. You get far more shades, tools and a mirror, plus 1,462 ratings instead of 1, which makes it the lower-risk buy.

Which is better for travel?

The SHANY kit. It is described as compact and travel-friendly, while the Miss Rose box weighs 0.91 kg and measures about 26 x 18 x 11 cm.

Do either include foundation?

Only the SHANY kit lists foundation. Miss Rose includes 4 compact powder shades for a matte base instead.

Which lasts longer on the skin?

Miss Rose states waterproof, long-wearing formulas. SHANY claims water resistance only, so Miss Rose is the better bet for long days.

Makeup Kit with Foundation Blush Eyeshadow Palette Mascara and Brush vs 58 Colors Professional Makeup Kit for Women Full Kit

Buy the Miss Rose 58 Colors kit if you want range and value: 39 eyeshadows, 6 blushes, 4 powders, 3 lipsticks, liners, glitter, brushes and a mirror, rated 4.3 from 1,462 ratings. Buy the SHANY All About That Face kit if you want a compact beginner set with foundation, blush, eyeshadow, mascara and a brush in one box. The Miss Rose kit is the safer pick on evidence; the SHANY set has only 1 rating, so its 5.0 score tells you little.

Ask our shopping agent