Marc Fisher Leonna Pointed Toe Bootie vs Naturalizer Delaney Ankle Bootie

The Naturalizer Delaney is the better pick for all-day wear. It has a 2.38-inch block heel, arch support, cushioning, a wide (D) width option and a rubber outsole, and owners of Naturalizer's comfort line consistently praise how it feels on long days. The Marc Fisher Leonna is the dressier shoe: a 1.5-inch wrapped block heel, a pointed toe, leather or suede uppers and a leather insole in a sleeker silhouette. Build quality is close, but the Leonna's leather insole and upper feel more refined while the Delaney's faux-leather options and synthetic lining feel more utilitarian. Buy the Leonna for a polished look with a low heel; buy the Delaney if comfort and support matter more than style.

• Choose the Marc Fisher Leonna if you want a pointed-toe dress bootie with a low wrapped block heel and leather or suede uppers for work or evenings out.
• Choose the Naturalizer Delaney if you need arch support, cushioning and a wide fit for standing or walking all day.