Naturalizer Delaney Ankle Bootie vs Rockport Carly Side Zip Ankle Bootie

The Naturalizer Delaney is the better pick for anyone who needs arch support and a wide fit, with a cushioned, stable footbed and a 2.38-inch block heel. The Rockport Carly is the cleaner, lighter-looking boot, with a full leather upper, a lower 1.38-inch stacked heel and truTECH heel and forefoot cushioning, and its 4.8-out-of-5 owner rating is strong. Build is close: both are leather-or-faux-leather uppers on rubber soles with side zips. Choose the Delaney for support and width, the Carly for a lower, dressier profile.

• Choose the Naturalizer Delaney if you want built-in arch support, a wide D width and a taller block heel for all-day standing.
• Choose the Rockport Carly if you want a genuine leather upper, a low stacked heel and a sleeker silhouette with truTECH cushioning.