Nine West Maribu Ankle Boot vs Naturalizer Delaney Ankle Bootie

The Naturalizer Delaney is the better boot for walking and all-day wear. It has a rubber outsole, arch support, a wide width option and a taller 4.72-inch shaft, and Naturalizer's comfort reputation is well earned. The Nine West Maribu is the dressier pick: a 1.75-inch block heel, pointy toe and suede or pony-hair finishes in prints like leopard. Owners of pointed suede booties like this one tend to praise the look and warn about break-in and slick soles. Choose the Delaney for comfort and the Maribu for style.

• Choose the Nine West Maribu if you want a pointed, heeled suede bootie for dresses, skirts and nights out.
• Choose the Naturalizer Delaney if you need a cushioned, supportive boot for standing, walking and everyday wear.