Which is better for a painful cut right now?

Product A. Its lidocaine numbs quickly, while product B's pain reliever takes about 15 minutes.

Product B. It has 1 oz versus 0.5 oz, so it lasts about twice as long at the same usage rate.

Is product B worth the extra $1.71?

Yes for regular use. You get double the ointment for about $1.71 more, roughly $9.99 per ounce versus $16.56.

Can I use either on a burn?

Both are labeled for minor cuts, scrapes and burns. Do not use them on deep or infected wounds; see a doctor.

Are they the same antibiotic?

Yes. Both use bacitracin zinc, neomycin sulfate and polymyxin B sulfate. They differ in the pain reliever and the size.

Which is better for a first-aid kit?

Product B for a household kit because of the larger size and lower cost per ounce. Product A suits a small travel kit.

Neosporin + Lidocaine Antibiotic Ointment vs Neosporin + Pain Relief Ointment

Both are Neosporin triple-antibiotic ointments with a pain reliever, so the real choice is size and price. Product A adds lidocaine and comes in a 0.5 oz tube for $8.28 at Walmart as of November 7, 2026. Product B is a 1 oz tube (listed as a 3-piece multipack) for $9.99 at Amazon as of November 7, 2026, which is far more ointment per dollar. Buy B for a family first-aid kit and A for a small kit or handbag where fast numbing matters.

Today the Neosporin + Lidocaine Antibiotic Ointment costs $1.50 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.