On Cloudhorizon Waterproof Women's Hiking Shoe vs FitVille Men's Extra Wide Hiking Shoes

These are not really rivals: the On Cloudhorizon is a women's waterproof trail shoe with a rocker sole and max cushioning, while the FitVille is a men's budget-friendly wide-fit hiker built for 2E to 4E feet. The On wins on traction, weather protection and weight, and its 4.6 rating from 177 owners backs that up. The FitVille wins only if width is the deciding factor, and its 4.4 score comes from just 15 ratings, so treat it as thin evidence.

• Choose the On Cloudhorizon Waterproof if you are a woman with average-width feet who hikes in rain and wants a light, cushioned shoe with reliable grip.
• Choose the FitVille if you are a man with wide or extra-wide feet who needs room across the forefoot and a supportive arch more than waterproofing.