On Cloudhorizon Waterproof Women's Hiking Shoe vs Kenetrek Bridger Low Hiking Shoes

Buy the On Cloudhorizon Waterproof for a light, cushioned women's hiker on maintained trails and wet days. Buy the Kenetrek Bridger Low for a heavier, stiffer men's shoe that holds up on rough ground and comes in wide widths. The On wins on weight and comfort out of the box; the Kenetrek wins on durability and fit range. Owners of the On praise the cushioning and grip but note the soft mesh upper and limited width options. Kenetrek buyers value the arch support and abrasion resistance but accept the extra weight.

• Choose the On Cloudhorizon Waterproof if you want a light, plush women's hiker for day trails, wet weather and all-day comfort.
• Choose the Kenetrek Bridger Low if you need a tough men's low hiker for uneven terrain, with wide sizing and firm arch support.