Which is better for day hikes?

The On Cloudhorizon. It weighs 280 g against 530 g and has max cushioning, so it is less tiring on moderate trails.

The Keen Targhee IV. Its nubuck leather upper and glue-free KEEN.FUSION bond outlast the On's textile upper.

Is the Keen worth the extra money?

If you carry a pack on rough ground, yes. At $157.44 at Amazon it costs $22.46 more than the On at $134.98 at ShopSimon and gives more support and durability.

Which fits wide feet?

The Keen. Its Original Fit gives generous space across the forefoot; the On uses a standard women's fit.

Which is better for plantar fasciitis?

The On is listed as suitable for plantar fasciitis with neutral to moderate arch support. The Keen's removable insole lets you swap in an orthotic.

Can I wear either as an everyday shoe?

Yes. The On is listed for everyday wear and is the lighter, less bulky option; the Keen is fine for casual wear but heavy.

On Women's Cloudhorizon Waterproof vs Men's Targhee IV Waterproof Hiking Shoe

These are different shoes for different feet. The On Cloudhorizon is a light, cushioned women's hiker at 280 g with a 6 mm drop; the Keen Targhee IV is a heavier men's leather hiker at 530 g with a 12 mm drop and a wide Original Fit. As of November 4, 2026, the On is cheaper at $134.98 at ShopSimon versus $157.44 at Amazon for the Keen. Buy the On for light, fast day hikes and the Keen for loaded packs, rough trails and long wear.

Today the On Women's Cloudhorizon Waterproof costs $22.46 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.