Which set is better for blending and shading?

Castle Art Supplies is the stronger choice on paper, since its listing is built around blending, shading and layering. ColorIt's soft wax cores also blend well, but buyers report more breakage when sharpening.

Which one is better for travel?

ColorIt, because it includes a compact nylon travel case with a spot for the sharpener. Castle ships in a display tin, which protects pencils but is bulkier to carry.

Do Castle pencils work with water?

The listing says watercolor effect yes, so you can try light water blending. Treat it as a bonus, not a full watercolor pencil replacement, and test on scrap paper first.

Is the ColorIt set worth it over Castle?

Only if you value the bundled case, sharpener, organizer, mini book and gift box. If you mainly want the pencils, Castle's $30.00 to $39.99 daily price range is the simpler comparison.

Castle claims a strong lead core, while ColorIt buyers frequently report snapping leads and splitting barrels. On that evidence Castle is likely to hold up better, though both are soft cores that wear down fast with heavy use.

Are these good for kids?

Castle lists kids and adults as its age range. ColorIt's small sharpener and mini book suit older kids and adults better than young children.

Premium 72 Colored Pencil Set vs Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils Set

Both are 72-count soft wax pencil sets aimed at colorists, but they differ in what comes in the box and how the cores behave. Castle Art Supplies is the safer pick for blending, layering and watercolor-style work, while ColorIt bundles more accessories for gifting and travel. Castle's recent daily price ran $30.00 to $39.99, so check the current store price against ColorIt's listing before you commit.

Ask our shopping agent