Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils vs Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils Set

Buy the Prismacolor Premier if you want the strongest pigment laydown and the most forgiving blending, especially for layered colored-pencil work on toned or textured paper. Buy the Castle Art Supplies 72 set if you want a broad 72-color range in a sturdy tin and a softer, easier core for casual coloring, sketching and travel. Reviewers and owners consistently rate Prismacolor higher for professional results, but note its soft cores break easily and need careful sharpening; Castle owners praise the tin and value but report harder, less blendable cores and occasional breakage.

• Choose the Prismacolor Premier if you are a serious artist who layers and blends heavily and will accept softer, more fragile cores for richer color.
• Choose the Castle Art Supplies 72 set if you want a wide color range in a protective tin for coloring, sketching and everyday use at a lower commitment.