Which is better for four smokers at once?

The Xikar. It has four cigar slots and a stated capacity of up to four cigars. The Prestige lists no slots or capacity.

Is the Xikar worth the extra $5?

Yes for most buyers. At $39.99 versus $34.95 as of November 7, 2026, the Xikar adds four slots, a 440 g ceramic body, and published dimensions.

Which lasts longer outdoors?

Stainless steel generally holds up better to weather and drops. Ceramic is heavier and more stable but can chip. The Prestige's 30-day warranty is short either way.

The Xikar measures 257 x 150 x 38 mm. The Prestige lists only a 24.0 inch height, so compare the footprint before buying.

Which is cheaper right now?

The Prestige at $34.95 at Best Buy as of November 7, 2026. The Xikar is $39.99 at Goombah's Cigar Lounge on the same date.

Prestige Smokin Quadrangle Cigar Ashtray vs Xikar Ceramic Ashtray

Buy the Xikar Ceramic Ashtray if you want a proper four-cigar rest with real dimensions and a known brand behind it. Buy the Prestige Smokin Quadrangle only if you want a stainless steel look and the lower price. The gap is small: $34.95 at Best Buy versus $39.99 at Goombah's Cigar Lounge, both as of November 7, 2026.

Today the Prestige Smokin Quadrangle Cigar Ashtray costs $5.04 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.