Which ashtray is better for outdoor use?

The Club Macanudo is better because it is made of melamine, which is weather-resistant and won't shatter if it blows off a table.

Can the Xikar hold large ring gauge cigars?

Yes, its 257mm length and wide slits are designed to accommodate up to four large cigars comfortably.

Is the Macanudo ashtray easy to clean?

Yes, it is dishwasher safe, making it much easier to maintain than the ceramic Xikar which requires hand wiping.

Which one feels more premium?

The Xikar feels more premium due to the weight and heat-resistance of ceramic, whereas the Macanudo has a more utilitarian, plastic-like feel.

Xikar Ceramic Ashtray vs Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray

The Xikar Ceramic Ashtray is the superior choice for indoor lounges due to its premium ceramic build and four-cigar capacity. The Club Macanudo is better for patio use because its melamine construction is shatterproof and dishwasher safe. At $19.95 at Walmart as of November 7, 2026, the Macanudo is slightly more affordable than the $23.44 Xikar at eBay.

Today the Club Macanudo Square Cigar Ashtray costs $3.49 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.