Proper Cloth Non-Iron Custom Dress Shirt vs Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt

Buy the Proper Cloth if fit is your main problem: it is made to your measurements, with your choice of collar, cuff, placket and fabric, so the shirt sits right at the shoulders and neck. Buy the Brooks Brothers if you want a proven off-the-rack shirt with a little stretch and Supima cotton, and one of its three fits already suits you. On build, Brooks Brothers leans on decades of non-iron finishing and long-staple cotton; Proper Cloth leans on made-to-measure construction. Owners of both praise the non-iron finish, and the common complaint about Proper Cloth is the wait and the need to dial in measurements on a first order.

• Choose the Proper Cloth Non-Iron Custom Dress Shirt if you have trouble finding an off-the-rack fit or want to specify collar, cuff and fabric.
• Choose the Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt if you want a ready-made shirt with stretch, Supima cotton and a choice of Regular, Traditional or Slim fit.