StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt vs Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt

The Brooks Brothers shirt is the better pick for most people who want a dress shirt that feels good and holds up: Supima cotton with 4% spandex in a twill weave, a spread Ainsley collar, and a French placket. The Paul Fredrick is a solid classic-fit poplin shirt with contrast trim inside the neckband and cuffs, longer tails, and break-resistant buttons, and its 4.4/5 from 95 ratings shows owners like the fit and non-iron finish. Choose Brooks Brothers for fabric quality and a modern collar; choose Paul Fredrick for a traditional button-down look with contrast detailing and a roomier classic fit.

  • Choose the Paul Fredrick if you want a classic-fit button-down collar shirt with contrast trim inside the neckband and cuffs and longer tails that stay tucked.
  • Choose the Brooks Brothers if you want Supima cotton with a touch of stretch, a spread Ainsley collar, and a French placket in regular, traditional, or slim fits.

Prices

  • Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt: $89.00 at Paul Fredrick (last seen Nov 10)
  • Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt: $83.59 at Amazon (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt is $5.41 cheaper than the Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt at the latest prices (Nov 10)
N
Non-Iron Cotton Solid Button Down Collar Dress Shirt With Contrast Trim - Navy

Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt

Non-Iron Cotton Solid Button Down Collar Dress Shirt With Contrast Trim - Navy

4.4(95 ratings)
$89.00at Paul FredrickChecked Nov 10
See all prices and details
Visit Paul Fredrick
Pros
  • Contrast fabric inside the neckband and cuffs adds a subtle detail
  • Longer tails stay tucked through the day
  • Break-resistant buttons dyed to match
  • Owners praise the fit, construction, and non-iron finish
Cons
  • Classic fit only, no slim or tailored option
  • Poplin with no stretch feels stiffer than a stretch twill
  • Buttonholes are tight at first, per owner feedback
Brooks Brothers
Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt

Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt

$83.59at AmazonChecked 21 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

Pros
  • Supima cotton with 4% spandex moves with you
  • Non-iron finish keeps it wrinkle-free all day
  • Three fits cover more body types
  • Spread Ainsley collar and French placket look sharp with or without a tie

What separates them

Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress ShirtBrooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt
CollarButton-down collar, 1/4'' topstitchedAinsley spread collar, no buttons
FabricNon-iron cotton poplin, no stretchNon-iron Supima cotton twill with 4% spandex
PlacketTop center placketSleek French placket
CuffsButton cuffs, 1/4'' topstitchedDouble-button barrel cuff
Fit optionsClassic fit onlyRegular, traditional, and slim fits
DetailingContrast fabric inside neckband and cuffs, split yoke, single rounded pocketClean front, no contrast trim, no chest pocket
Shirt tailLonger tails designed to stay tucked inStandard tail length
ButtonsDyed-to-match break-resistant buttonsStandard buttons

Price history

$96.00$76.80
Nov 2Nov 10
  • Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt: lowest $89.00 on Nov 10 at Paul Fredrick.
  • Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt: lowest $76.80 on Nov 10 at Brooks Brothers.

Prices at every store

Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt

  • Paul FredrickNew

    In stock

    $89.00Checked Nov 10
    Visit Paul Fredrick
  • ShopSimonNew

    In stock

    $119.00Checked Nov 10
    Visit ShopSimon

Also available at

  • Paul FredrickCheck price at Paul Fredrick
All 2 stores and price history →

Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt

  • Brooks BrothersNew

    In stock

    $76.80+ $10.95 shippingChecked 21 h ago
    Visit Brooks Brothers
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $83.59Free shippingChecked 21 h ago
    Visit Amazon
  • ModeSensNew

    Availability unknown

    $96.00Checked 21 h ago
    Visit ModeSens
All 3 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecPaul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress ShirtBrooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt
Collar styleButton Down Collar, 1/4'' Topstitched—
Cuff styleButton Cuffs, 1/4'' Topstitched—
Button typeDyed To Match Break Resistant Buttons—
Contrast detailContrast Fabric Inside Neckband And Cuffs—
Shirt tailLonger Tails Designed To Stay Tucked In—
PlacketTop Center Placket—
YokeSplit Yoke—
PocketSingle Front Rounded Pocket—
FabricNon-iron Cotton In Poplin Weave—
CareMachine Wash Warm Like Colors, Tumble Dry—
OriginImported—
FitClassic Fit—

What reviewers say

Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt

  • 4.4 / 595 ratings

Buyers rate it 4.4 out of 5 and single out the fit, the stylish look and the quality of the cotton. Most say it comes out of the wash without ironing. The recurring complaint is tight buttonholes.

What people mention
  • FitPraisedBuyers repeatedly say the classic fit lands well through the chest and shoulders.
  • Non-ironPraisedOwners report it comes out of the dryer wearable without pressing.
  • Fabric feelPraisedThe poplin is described as good material with a pleasant hand.
  • ConstructionPraisedReviewers call the stitching and overall build excellent for the type.

Questions and answers

Which is better for wearing with a tie?
The Brooks Brothers Ainsley spread collar frames a tie knot better than a button-down collar. The Paul Fredrick button-down works with a tie but reads more casual.
Which feels more comfortable all day?
The Brooks Brothers, because the 4% spandex in the twill gives it stretch. The Paul Fredrick poplin is crisp and non-iron but has no give.
Which lasts longer?
Supima's extra-long staple fibers resist pilling and hold color well, so the Brooks Brothers should outlast the Paul Fredrick over years of washing. Both are machine washable and non-iron.
Is the Brooks Brothers worth stepping up to?
Yes if you want stretch, Supima cotton, and a choice of three fits. The Paul Fredrick is the better choice if you specifically want a button-down collar with contrast trim.
Which fits a fuller build?
The Paul Fredrick classic fit is roomy, and Brooks Brothers' traditional fit is its fullest cut. Brooks Brothers also offers regular and slim, so it covers more shapes.
Which is better in hot weather?
The Paul Fredrick poplin is lighter and breathes better than the Brooks Brothers twill. The twill's stretch helps comfort but traps more heat.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Non-Iron Cotton Solid Button Down Collar Dress Shirt With Contrast Trim - Navy vs Non-Iron Cotton Pinpoint Solid Button Down Collar Dress Shirt - White
  • Non-Iron Cotton Solid Button Down Collar Dress Shirt With Contrast Trim - Navy vs Non-Iron Cotton Check Button Down Collar Dress Shirt With Contrast Trim - Blue
  • Non-Iron Cotton Solid Button Down Collar Dress Shirt With Contrast Trim - Navy vs Proper Cloth Non-Iron Custom Dress Shirt
  • Proper Cloth Non-Iron Custom Dress Shirt vs Brooks Brothers Non-Iron Stretch Supima Cotton Dress Shirt

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best men's long-sleeve button-up dress shirts
  • Best men's shirts
Cons
  • No contrast trim or chest pocket
  • Spread collar is less casual than a button-down
  • Twill is heavier than poplin in hot weather