Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt vs Proper Cloth Non-Iron Custom Dress Shirt

Buy the Paul Fredrick if you want a classic-fit, non-iron poplin shirt with contrast trim and a button-down collar, and you like the idea of longer tails that stay tucked. Buy the Proper Cloth if fit is the deciding factor: it is made to your measurements, so sleeve length, chest and collar size are set by you rather than by a size chart. On construction the two are close, both non-iron cotton poplin with stitched collars and cuffs; the Paul Fredrick wins on contrast detailing and off-the-rack simplicity, the Proper Cloth wins on fit and fabric choice. Owners of the Paul Fredrick rate it 4.4 out of 5 and praise the fit and non-iron finish, with tight buttonholes the main complaint.

• Choose the Paul Fredrick if you want a ready-to-wear classic fit with contrast inside the neckband and cuffs, and you would rather not measure yourself.
• Choose the Proper Cloth if standard sizes never fit you well and you want the collar, sleeves and body cut to your own measurements.