Schylling Classic Rubber Duckies vs Munchkin White Hot Safety Bath Ducky

Buy the Munchkin White Hot Ducky if the duck is for a baby's bath. Its color-changing disc tells you when the water is too hot, and the sealed, mildew-resistant body holds up to daily tub use. The Schylling Classic is a plain 12-pack of small rubber ducks for party favors, collecting and splash-park play, not a bath thermometer. Reviewers rate the Munchkin well at 4.6 out of 5 from 458 ratings; the Schylling ducks are simple toys with holes in the bottom and no squeaker.

• Choose the Schylling Classic if you want a batch of small yellow ducks for party favors, a collection or splash-park play.
• Choose the Munchkin White Hot Ducky if you need a bath safety check for a baby and want a toy that resists mildew.