Schylling Classic Rubber Duckies vs Playgro Bath Duckie Family

Buy the Playgro Bath Duckie Family for actual bath and water play with babies and toddlers. It floats, squirts, is fully sealed against mold, and is safe to chew. The Schylling Classic is a 12-pack of small yellow ducks with holes in the bottom that do not float upright and do not squeak, so it suits party favors, collecting and dry play rather than the tub. Owners of sealed ducks like the Playgro set for lasting through daily baths; the Schylling ducks are simple, BPA-free and cheap to hand out in bulk.

• Choose the Schylling Classic if you want a bulk set of small yellow ducks for party favors, cake toppers or a collection, and the bath is not the point.
• Choose the Playgro Bath Duckie Family if you need floating, squirting bath toys for a baby or toddler that will not trap water and grow mold.