Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic vs Quackbang Grenade Rubber Duck
Buy the Quackbang Grenade if you want a duck that actually floats upright, stays clean and looks good on a shelf. Buy the Schylling Yellow Classic if you need a cheap 12-pack for a party, a splash park or a kid's bath toy. The Classic has ranged from $4.99 to $8.99 since October 29, 2026; no price was given for the Quackbang.
Ask our shopping agent
Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic
Choose the Schylling Yellow Classic if you want a low-cost 12-pack of BPA-free ducks for party favors, splash-park play or bath time with kids aged 1 to 6.
Pros
- 12 ducks per pack, so the cost per duck is low
- BPA-free rubber
- Small 3-inch size suits toddler hands
- Cheap enough to give away as party favors
Cons
- Does not float upright
- Holes in the bottom let water in and are hard to dry
- No squeaker
- Plain design with no collector appeal
What separates them
| Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic | Quackbang Grenade Rubber Duck | |
|---|---|---|
| Float behavior | Holes in the bottom; does not float upright | Made to float upright |
| Water and grime | Open holes let water in and trap moisture | Sealed to stay clean |
| Material safety | BPA free | Phthalate free |
| Quantity and price per duck | 12 ducks per pack | Sold as a single duck |
| Size | 3.00 x 3.00 x 2.50 inches | 3.5 x 2.75 x 3.5 inches |
| Sound | Does not squeak | No squeaker listed |
| Collectibility | Plain classic yellow duck, sold in bulk | Limited edition with detailed sculpting and box designs |
| Stated age range |
Price history
$24.99$4.99
- Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic: lowest $4.99 on Oct 29 at Lucky Duck Toys; $8.99 on Nov 1.
- Quackbang Grenade Rubber Duck: lowest $24.99 on Oct 29.
Prices at every store
Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic
- Learning Express Toys & Gifts - Newton MACheck price at Learning Express Toys & Gifts - Newton MA
- ZurchersCheck price at Zurchers
- Piccolo Mondo ToysCheck price at Piccolo Mondo Toys
Quackbang Grenade Rubber Duck
- Bunker Branding Co.Check price at Bunker Branding Co.
Specs compared
| Spec | Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic | Quackbang Grenade Rubber Duck |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensions | 3.00 x 3.00 x 2.50 inches | 3.5 x 2.75 x 3.5 inches |
| Recommended For Ages | 1 to 6. | — |
| Brand | Schylling | — |
| Recommended Ages | 1 to 6 | — |
| Gender | Both | — |
| Type | Rubber duck | — |
| Animal Type | Duck | — |
| Primary Material | Rubber | — |
| Material Free Of | BPA free | — |
| Safety Highlights | BPA Free | — |
| Floating |
What reviewers say
Rubber Duckies Yellow Classic
Owner feedback on this style of Schylling duck is mixed. People like the classic look and the low price per duck, but many complain that the bottom holes trap water and the ducks stop floating upright.
Pros
- Classic look kids enjoy
- Good value in a 12-pack
- Small size suits toddlers
Cons
- Water gets inside through the bottom holes
- Do not float upright
- No squeaker
Questions and answers
- Which duck is better for a baby's bath?
- The Quackbang. It floats upright and is sealed, so water and grime stay out. The Classic has holes in the bottom that trap water.
- Which is better for a party favor?
- The Schylling Classic. One pack gives you 12 ducks, which covers a small party at a low cost per duck.
- Does the Classic duck float?
- It floats, but the listing says it does not float upright because of the holes in the bottom.
- Is the Quackbang worth the extra cost?
- If you want one duck that floats properly, stays clean and looks good on a shelf, yes. If you need many ducks for kids to lose or give away, the Classic pack is the better value.
- Which one lasts longer?
- The Quackbang should hold up better in water because it is sealed. The Classic's open bottom lets water sit inside, which can lead to mildew.
- Are either of them safe for young kids?
- The Classic is labeled BPA free and recommended for ages 1 to 6. The Quackbang is phthalate free and marketed for all ages.