StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Saucony Shadow 5000 vs ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0

The GEL-NYC 2.0 is the better all-round pick for most people: it has more cushioning tech (FF BLAST PLUS, GEL in heel and forefoot, TRUSSTIC support, AHAR rubber) and a higher owner rating from a larger pool. The Shadow 5000 is the cleaner retro look in suede and mesh and suits casual wear and standing, but owners report stitching failures and a narrow, small-running fit. Buy the ASICS for comfort and durability; buy the Saucony for style and a lower-profile retro shape.

  • Choose the Saucony Shadow 5000 if you want a slim retro suede-and-mesh sneaker for casual outfits and light standing, and you can size up or try it on first.
  • Choose the ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0 if you want the more cushioned, more supportive shoe for all-day walking and you value a stronger owner rating.

Prices

  • Saucony Shadow 5000: $54.00 at Macy's (last seen Nov 18)
  • ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0: $44.00 at SLAMJAMSHOPS (last seen Nov 11)
  • Difference: the ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0 is $10.00 cheaper than the Saucony Shadow 5000 at the latest prices (Nov 11 and Nov 18)
Saucony
Saucony Shadow 5000

Saucony Shadow 5000

4.3(251 ratings)
$54.00at Macy'sChecked 18 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Macy's
Pros
  • Classic retro silhouette in suede and mesh
  • Light and low to the ground
  • Comfortable for standing and casual days, owners say
  • Wide range of colorways and sizes
Cons
  • Reported toe stitching failures
  • Runs small and narrow for many buyers
  • Colors can differ from photos
  • Firm EVA midsole with no gel or advanced foam
ASICS
GEL-NYC 2.0

ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0

GEL-NYC 2.0

4.7(582 ratings)
$44.00at SLAMJAMSHOPSChecked Nov 11
See all prices and details
Visit SLAMJAMSHOPS
Pros
  • FF BLAST PLUS foam plus GEL in heel and forefoot
  • TRUSSTIC support and AHAR outsole add stability and wear
  • Higher owner rating from more than twice as many ratings
  • Reflective details and layered upper look premium
Cons
  • Owners report a tight toe box
  • Described as heavy
  • Hard sole under the ball of the foot for some
  • Not built for running despite the running-derived design

What separates them

Saucony Shadow 5000ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0
CushioningEVA foam midsole, basic and firmFF BLAST PLUS midsole with GEL in heel and forefoot
SupportArch support insole, no stability structureTRUSSTIC support unit under the midfoot
Outsole durabilityXT-600 triangular lug rubberAHAR rubber, ASICS' abrasion-resistant compound
UpperSuede, mesh and leather overlays in a retro panel layoutMesh with gradient overlays, synthetic leather and reflective hits
FitOwners say it runs small and narrowSnug heel but a tight toe box reported by some
WeightLight, low-profile rideOwners describe it as heavy
Build quality reportsToe stitching unravels on some pairsFewer durability complaints; materials praised
Owner rating4.3 from 251 ratings4.7 from 582 ratings

Price history

$75.00$54.00
Nov 11Nov 19
  • Saucony Shadow 5000: lowest $54.00 on Nov 15 at Macy's; $70.00 on Nov 19.
  • ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0: lowest $69.99 on Nov 19 at Amazon.

Prices at every store

Saucony Shadow 5000

  • Macy'sNew

    In stock

    $54.00Free shippingChecked 18 h ago
    Visit Macy's
  • 6pm.comNew

    In stock

    $69.00+ $3.95 shippingChecked Nov 12
    Visit 6pm.com
  • Shop SimonNew

    In stock

    $70.00+ $4.95 shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Shop Simon
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $74.75Free shippingChecked 18 h ago
    Visit Amazon

Also available at

  • WalmartCheck price at Walmart

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 25 stores and price history →

ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0

  • WelcomeNew

    In stockPriced in EUR (€66.67)Return policy

    $74.18Checked Nov 11
    Visit Welcome
  • sneakersnstuff.comNew

    In stockMade for another market

    $74.55Checked 5 h ago
    Visit sneakersnstuff.com
  • SLAMJAMSHOPSNew

    Availability unknownShips from abroad · duties may applyReturn policy

    $44.00Checked Nov 11
    Visit SLAMJAMSHOPS
  • ssense.comNew

    Availability unknown

    $75.00Checked 5 h ago
    Visit ssense.com

Also available at

  • eBayCheck price at eBay
  • Extra ButterCheck price at Extra Butter

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 80 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecSaucony Shadow 5000ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0
MaterialSuede, Mesh, RubberGenuine Leather, Genuine Suede, Mesh, Rubber
Upper MaterialMesh, Suede, LeatherSYNTHETIC LEATHER
WidthNormalWidth Medium
DepartmentMen's, Women's, UnisexMen's, Women's, Unisex
Fashion SneakerYesYes
Closure StyleLace-upLace-up
StyleCasualCasual
TypeSneakersSneakers
BreathableYesYes
Support TypeCushioningCushioning, Stability
Outsole MaterialRubber OutsoleRubber Outsole
Shoe size12 Men—
Show all 40 specsShow fewer specs
SpecSaucony Shadow 5000ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0
BrandSaucony—
ColorRed—
Shoe widthMedium—
Casual & dress shoe styleNon-Performance Sneakers—
Shoe heel styleBlock—
Toe styleClosed Toe—
Shoe closureLace-Up—
Clothing occasionCasual—
Footwear featureArch Support, Foam Cushioning—
Age group

What reviewers say

Saucony Shadow 5000

  • 4.3 / 5251 ratings

Owners rate the Shadow 5000 well overall, with most praise going to comfort and the retro look. Complaints center on sizing, stitching that comes apart near the toes, and colors that arrive different from what was shown.

What people mention
  • ComfortPraisedOwners say the cushioned midsole makes them comfortable for all-day wear and long periods of standing.
  • StylePraisedBuyers like the layered retro look and the suede and mesh mix.
  • FitMixedSome say they run narrow or need a half size up, while others find them true to size.
  • BulkCriticisedA few find the shoe heavier and chunkier than they expected.

ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0

  • 4.7 / 5582 ratings

Shoppers are split. Many like the looks and find it comfortable for casual wear and short walks, while others report a tight toe box, a heavy feel and hard soles that wear poorly over longer periods.

What people mention
  • LooksPraisedOwners say the retro styling draws compliments and works well for casual outfits.
  • ComfortMixedMany find it comfortable for short walks, but others say it turns uncomfortable after an hour or more.
  • Toe boxCriticisedSome shoppers report a tight toe box that presses on the toes.
  • WeightCriticisedSeveral owners describe the shoe as heavy on foot.

Questions and answers

Which is better for standing all day?
The GEL-NYC 2.0. Its FF BLAST PLUS foam and dual GEL inserts absorb more impact than the Shadow 5000's plain EVA midsole. The Saucony is fine for shorter stretches but gets firm.
Which lasts longer?
The GEL-NYC 2.0 is the safer bet. Its AHAR outsole resists abrasion and owners report fewer build issues. Shadow 5000 owners report toe stitching coming apart.
Is the GEL-NYC 2.0 worth stepping up to over the Shadow 5000?
Yes if comfort and durability matter most. You get more cushioning, a support unit and a tougher outsole. Pick the Shadow 5000 if the retro suede look is the priority.
Do either run small?
Both can. Shadow 5000 owners often say it runs small and narrow, so consider a half size up. GEL-NYC 2.0 owners more often cite a tight toe box than overall length.
Can I run in either?
No. Both are casual sneakers. The GEL-NYC 2.0 borrows running tech but owners say the sole is hard for running, and the Shadow 5000 is a lifestyle shoe.
Which is lighter?
The Shadow 5000. It has a lower-profile EVA midsole, while GEL-NYC 2.0 owners describe their shoe as heavy.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Saucony Grid Jazz 9 vs GEL-NYC 2.0
  • Reebok Club C 85 Vintage Unisex Sneakers vs GEL-NYC 2.0
  • adidas Adistar XLG 2.0 Men's Shoes vs GEL-NYC 2.0
  • Nike Zoom Vomero 5 Women's Shoes vs GEL-NYC 2.0
  • Saucony Shadow 5000 vs Reebok Club C 85 Vintage Unisex Sneakers
  • adidas Stan Smith vs Saucony Shadow 5000
  • Nike Zoom Vomero 5 Women's Shoes vs Saucony Shadow 5000
  • Veja V-90 vs Saucony Shadow 5000

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best everyday sneakers
  • Best classic sneakers for everyday wear
  • Best sneakers
  • Best everyday sneakers for casual wear
  • Best everyday sneakers for adults
Adult
—
Shoe categoryMen's Shoes—
Heel height styleLow Heel—
Shoe sole materialRubber—
PatternColorblock—
Shoe size systemUS Women's—
Insole materialFoam—
GenderUnisex—
Gore-TexNo—
Manufacturer ColorBlack—
OutsoleRubber—
InsoleTextile—
Size (US)13, 14, 11, 12, 6.5, 5.5, 9.5, 10.5, 4.5, 8.5, …—
SeriesSaucony Shadow—
FasteningLaced—
LiningSynthetic, Suede, Textile—
MidsoleFoam, EVA—
Overlay type—Gradient overlays and unique mesh
Reflective details—forefoot, lace holder, heel TPU, and GEL™ techn…