Secure Mat Non-Slip Bath Mat vs Max Grip Bathtub Mat

Buy the Max Grip Bathtub Mat if you want a mat that locks onto the tub floor and stays put; its 200 suction cups and 176 drain holes are the more proven anti-slip design, and its 4.9 rating comes from a small base of 52 ratings. The Secure Mat is a softer, cushioned mat with an antibacterial treatment and a much larger review base of 2,320 ratings at 4.7, but it relies on a textured surface rather than suction cups, so it can shift on a wet tub floor. For safety in a tub or shower, the Max Grip is the stronger pick; for a plusher feel underfoot, the Secure Mat is the more comfortable one.

• Choose the Secure Mat if you want a soft, cushiony mat with an antibacterial treatment and a long track record across thousands of ratings.
• Choose the Max Grip Bathtub Mat if slip resistance is the priority and you want suction cups that hold the mat firmly to the tub floor.