Sherpa Lined Denim Jacket vs Carhartt Women's Relaxed Fit Denim Sherpa-Lined Jacket

Both are 12 oz-class sherpa-lined denim jackets, so the choice comes down to fit and detailing. The Sherpa Lined Denim Jacket is the more feature-loaded pick: full-length zipper, rib-knit cuffs and hem, a zippered sleeve pocket and an interior pocket, in a relaxed cut. The Carhartt is the safer, more established workwear choice with a loose fit, 100% cotton denim and a polyester fleece lining, and owners describe it as well made with an exceptional fit. Buy the first for pockets and a trimmer relaxed shape; buy the Carhartt for a roomier loose fit and a brand with a long workwear track record.

• Choose the Sherpa Lined Denim Jacket if you want a zippered front, stretch rib cuffs and hem, and extra pockets including a zippered sleeve pocket.
• Choose the Carhartt Women's Relaxed Fit Denim Sherpa-Lined Jacket if you want a roomier loose fit, 100% cotton denim and a workwear brand with a long track record.