Wrangler Retro Sherpa Lined Denim Jacket vs Carhartt Women's Relaxed Fit Denim Sherpa-Lined Jacket

Both are sherpa-lined denim jackets for women, so the choice comes down to closure and cut. The Wrangler Retro is a button-front, stretch-cotton jacket with a loose fit and a hip-length hem; owners rate it well but not exceptionally. The Carhartt is a heavier 12.25 oz 100% cotton denim with a zip front and a relaxed workwear cut, built for layering and hard wear. Buy the Wrangler for a softer, more casual look; buy the Carhartt if you want a sturdier jacket that holds up to daily use.

• Choose the Wrangler Retro if you want a button-front denim jacket with stretch in the fabric and a softer, more casual look.
• Choose the Carhartt if you want a heavier, zip-front denim jacket built for layering and rough daily wear.