Wrangler Retro Sherpa Lined Denim Jacket vs Carhartt Women's Relaxed Fit Denim Sherpa-Lined Jacket

Buy the Wrangler for a fitted, classic denim jacket with a Western yoke and button front. Buy the Carhartt for a roomier workwear layer with a zip front and fleece lining. The Wrangler uses 11.5 oz stretch denim with a cotton-rich body and a polyester sherpa lining, and owners like the shape and the western look. The Carhartt is a looser 12.25 oz all-cotton shell with a zip closure, which reviewers tend to favor for layering over sweaters and for cold-weather chores.

• Choose the Wrangler if you want a trimmer, Western-styled denim jacket with a button front and stretch for everyday wear.
• Choose the Carhartt if you want a relaxed, roomier jacket with a zip front and fleece lining for layering and outdoor work.