STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet vs STAINMASTER Welcome Retreat III Carpet
Both are STAINMASTER polyester textured carpets with stain and soil resistance, so the real choice is face weight and pile. Welcome Retreat III is the denser, taller carpet at 68.3 oz per square yard and 0.82 in pile, which gives a fuller, softer feel and better crush recovery in busy rooms. Effortless Appeal II at 58.5 oz is the lighter, lower-profile option that suits stairs, low-clearance doors and tighter budgets. Owners of STAINMASTER polyester lines generally report easy spot cleaning and good color retention, but polyester still mats in high-traffic paths over time, so denser wins for longevity.
- Choose the Effortless Appeal II if you want a lower, tighter pile for stairs, doors with little clearance, or a room where a lighter carpet is easier to handle.
- Choose the Welcome Retreat III if you want the denser, taller carpet for a living room or bedroom where softness underfoot and crush resistance matter most.
Prices
- STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet: $4.76 at Saber Sales (last seen Nov 15)
- STAINMASTER Welcome Retreat III Carpet: $4.99 at Saber Sales (checked today)
- Difference: the STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet is $0.23 cheaper than the STAINMASTER Welcome Retreat III Carpet at the latest prices (Nov 15 and Nov 16)

