StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet vs STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet

Buy the PetProtect Best Of Breed if pets, kids or a busy household are the reason you are replacing carpet. Its nylon face and moisture-barrier pad pairing target pet stains and odor directly, and the warranty package is the stronger of the two. The Effortless Appeal II is the softer, denser-feeling polyester carpet with a multi-tonal look that hides footprints and traffic marks better, but polyester is the less resilient fiber and it lacks the pet-specific odor claim. Owners of both report the stain resistance holds up; the real split is nylon durability and pet focus versus a plusher, more forgiving visual texture.

  • Choose the STAINMASTER PetProtect Best Of Breed if you have pets or heavy traffic and want nylon durability with a stain, soil and odor warranty behind it.
  • Choose the STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II if you want a denser, softer carpet with a multi-tone look that masks dirt and footprints in bedrooms and living rooms.

Prices

  • STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet: $5.19 at Saber Sales (checked today)
  • STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet: $4.76 at Saber Sales (last seen Nov 15)
  • Difference: the STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet is $0.43 cheaper than the STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet at the latest prices (Nov 15 and Nov 16)
STAINMASTER
STAINMASTER PetProtect Best Of Breed I Rain Cloud Blue Nylon Textured Indoor Carpet

STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet

STAINMASTER PetProtect Best Of Breed I Rain Cloud Blue Nylon Textured Indoor Carpet

$5.19at Saber SalesChecked 54 min ago
See all prices and details
Visit Saber Sales
Pros
  • Nylon face resists crushing and wear better than polyester
  • Pet-focused stain, soil and odor resistance with the matching pad
  • Lifetime stain and soil warranty plus 25-year texture and wear coverage
  • Solid blue texture suits a clean, timeless room
  • Meets HUD/GHA UM-44D standards
Cons
  • Lighter face weight feels less plush than the polyester option
  • Solid color shows footprints and vacuum marks
  • Odor protection depends on using a STAINMASTER cushion
  • Limited color range in this style
Stainmaster
STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Cameo Brown 58.5-oz sq yard Polyester Textured Indoor Carpet

STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet

STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Cameo Brown 58.5-oz sq yard Polyester Textured Indoor Carpet

$4.76at Saber SalesChecked 1 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Saber Sales
Pros
  • Dense 58.5-oz face weight feels soft and substantial
  • Multi-tonal brown hides dirt, footprints and traffic patterns
  • Stain and soil resistance is easy to clean
  • Good fit for bedrooms and living rooms
  • Modern, fresh visual texture
Cons
  • Polyester crushes and mats faster in heavy traffic
  • No pet-specific odor claim
  • No stated 25-year texture retention warranty
  • Lighter shades in the line can still show soiling over time

What separates them

STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed CarpetSTAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet
Face fiberNylon, the more resilient fiber for crush recovery and wearPolyester, softer underfoot but mats and crushes sooner in high traffic
Face weight39 oz per square yard, medium weight58.5 oz per square yard, noticeably denser and plusher
Pet performanceMarketed for pets; helps prevent pet stains and reduce odor when paired with a STAINMASTER cushionGeneral stain and soil resistance, no pet-specific odor claim
Color and patternSolid color texture in Rain Cloud Blue, clean but shows marksMulti-tonal Cameo Brown texture hides footprints, vacuum lines and soil
WarrantyLifetime stain and soil, 25-year texture retention and abrasive wear, stairs includedStain and wear coverage typical of the STAINMASTER line, without the stated 25-year texture terms
Pile heightMedium pile at 0.430 inTextured pile built for a softer, springier feel
Best roomsFamily rooms, hallways, pet areas, anywhere traffic is heavyBedrooms, living rooms and quieter spaces where comfort matters most
Code complianceMeets HUD/GHA UM-44D minimum standards for FHA and HUD projectsNot stated as meeting that bulletin

Prices at every store

STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet

  • Saber SalesNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $5.19Checked 54 min ago
    Visit Saber Sales
Prices and history →

STAINMASTER Effortless Appeal II Carpet

  • Saber SalesNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $4.76Checked 1 h ago
    Visit Saber Sales
Prices and history →

Questions and answers

Which is better for a home with dogs and cats?
The PetProtect Best Of Breed. Its nylon face and the moisture-barrier STAINMASTER pad are built around pet stains and odor, and the warranty backs stain, soil and wear. The Effortless Appeal II resists stains but makes no odor claim.
Which carpet lasts longer in a busy hallway?
The PetProtect. Nylon recovers from crushing better than polyester, and it carries a 25-year texture retention and abrasive wear warranty with stairs included. The denser polyester feels better but mats sooner under constant traffic.
Is the Effortless Appeal II worth stepping up to over the PetProtect?
Step up if comfort and a forgiving multi-tone look matter more than pet performance. It is denser and softer underfoot and hides marks well. Skip it if you have pets or heavy traffic, where nylon wins.
Does the PetProtect really reduce pet odor?
The odor reduction is tied to pairing it with a STAINMASTER carpet cushion that has a moisture barrier. On its own the carpet resists stains and soil; the pad is what blocks moisture and odor from reaching the backing.
Which hides dirt better?
The Effortless Appeal II. Its multi-tonal Cameo Brown texture breaks up footprints, vacuum lines and light soil. The solid Rain Cloud Blue shows marks more readily, so it needs more frequent vacuuming.
Which is better for a basement or FHA project?
The PetProtect, which meets or exceeds HUD/GHA bulletin UM-44D minimum standards. The Effortless Appeal II is not stated as meeting that bulletin.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best Stainmaster carpets