STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet vs STAINMASTER Welcome Retreat III Carpet
Both are STAINMASTER nylon-free textured carpets with lifetime stain and soil warranties, so the choice comes down to fiber and pile. The Best Of Breed I is a 39-oz nylon in a medium 0.43-in pile with a 25-year texture retention warranty, and its pet odor and stain protection is tied to using a STAINMASTER pad with a moisture barrier. The Welcome Retreat III is a heavier 68.3-oz polyester in a taller 0.82-in pile with a 15-year texture warranty; it feels plusher underfoot but polyester mats and crushes faster than nylon in high traffic. Pick the nylon for busy halls and pets, the polyester for bedrooms and a softer, deeper look.
- Choose the STAINMASTER PetProtect Best Of Breed I if you have pets or heavy foot traffic and want the longer 25-year texture retention warranty and a lower, easier-to-clean pile.
- Choose the STAINMASTER Welcome Retreat III if you want a thicker, softer high-pile carpet for bedrooms or living rooms and prefer a multi-tonal look that hides marks.
Prices
- STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet: $5.19 at Saber Sales (checked today)
- STAINMASTER Welcome Retreat III Carpet: $4.99 at Saber Sales (checked today)
- Difference: the STAINMASTER Welcome Retreat III Carpet is $0.20 cheaper than the STAINMASTER PetProtect Best of Breed Carpet today

