Stressless Mayfair Recliner vs Ashley Luigi Oversized Chair

These are different chairs for different jobs. The Stressless Mayfair is a true recliner with a matching ottoman, a steel Flexo-spring frame and molded foam with Comfort Zones, and owners consistently praise its cushioning and how the Paloma leather wears in. The Luigi is a wide, fixed oversized chair with a 250 lb capacity, a wood frame and mixed leather and faux leather, so it seats two small people or one large one but does not recline. Buy the Mayfair for daily back support and lounging; buy the Luigi for a big, tufted seat in a casual living room.

• Choose the Stressless Mayfair if you want a recliner with an ottoman, adjustable support and leather that holds up to daily use.
• Choose the Luigi Oversized Chair if you want a broad, tufted seat for lounging sideways and do not need a recline.