Brogliano Oversized Chair vs Ashley Luigi Oversized Chair

Both are oversized leather-match chairs with loose seats and attached backs, so the real split is size and shape. The Brogliano is the bigger, deeper chair at 54 inches wide and 44 deep, with a platform foundation it says resists sagging better than springs. The Luigi is 4 inches narrower and 6 inches shorter, weighs 26 pounds less, and has tufting and a linear silhouette for a more tailored look. Pick the Brogliano for sprawl and the Luigi for a tighter footprint and cleaner lines.

• Choose the Brogliano Oversized Chair if you want the roomier seat, a deeper 44-inch footprint, and a platform base built to hold its shape.
• Choose the Luigi Oversized Chair if you want a lighter, lower chair with tufted detailing that fits a smaller corner.