Brogliano Oversized Chair vs Stressless Mayfair Recliner

The Brogliano is a big, wide lounge chair for sprawling with a book or a tablet; the Stressless Mayfair is a recliner built for one person to sit back and recline, and it comes with a matching ottoman. The Brogliano gives you more seat width and a leather seating surface for the money, but its sides and back are matched faux leather, and it does not recline. The Mayfair has Stressless's Flexo-spring suspension, cold-foam Comfort Zones and a steel frame, and owners say the Paloma leather softens into a patina over years of use. Buy the Brogliano for shared, roomy seating; buy the Mayfair for a single dedicated recline spot.

• Choose the Brogliano if you want a wide, deep chair two people can share or one person can sprawl in, and you don't need a recline mechanism.
• Choose the Stressless Mayfair if you want a proper recliner with an ottoman, spring suspension and leather that ages well, and you sit in it alone.